Under Canada’s Competition Act, posting fake reviews — including undisclosed reviews from employees, friends, or incentivized customers — is a form of deceptive marketing that carries significant penalties. This guide covers what qualifies as an illegal review under the Competition Act, which practices Brampton businesses most commonly overlook, and what to do if non-compliant reviews are already published. It is for Brampton business owners, marketing managers, and anyone managing online reputation who wants to understand the legal boundaries and avoid enforcement action from the Competition Bureau. This post is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice.
Key Takeaways
- Under the Competition Act, fake reviews and undisclosed insider reviews are classified as misleading representations.
- Employees, friends, or family who post reviews without disclosing their connection to the business create legal exposure for that business.
- Incentivized reviews must be clearly labeled — compensation of any kind, including discounts or free products, requires disclosure.
- Civil penalties for misleading representations can reach $10 million for a first violation; criminal provisions can result in imprisonment.
- Businesses that discover non-compliant reviews should audit, remove or correct them, and document all corrective steps taken.
- The Competition Act was amended on June 23, 2022, expanding the Bureau’s enforcement tools and penalty thresholds.

What the Competition Act Says About Fake Reviews
Canada’s Competition Act prohibits false or misleading representations made to the public in promoting a product or service. Under this framework, online reviews carry the same legal weight as any other marketing claim — manufactured, misleading, or undisclosed reviews can constitute deceptive marketing practices subject to both civil and criminal provisions of the Act.
The Competition Bureau treats a materially false or misleading claim as any representation that could affect a consumer’s decision to purchase. A five-star review from an employee posting as an independent customer meets that threshold. So does a review from a friend, a family member, or any person who received compensation without disclosing it. The Bureau’s Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest explicitly names undisclosed insider and incentivized reviews as enforcement priorities.
The Competition Act was amended on June 23, 2022, expanding enforcement tools and increasing administrative monetary penalties for deceptive marketing practices.
What Brampton Businesses Get Wrong
Undisclosed Employee Reviews Are Misleading Representations
The most commonly misunderstood violation under Canada’s Competition Act is posting reviews from employees, family, or friends without disclosure. Many business owners treat this as a harmless way to build early credibility — gathering reviews from people who know the business well. Under the Act, this constitutes a misleading representation because those reviewers hold a material connection to the business that customers cannot see.
The Competition Bureau clarified in January 2024 that businesses can be liable for reviews posted by their employees even when the employer did not explicitly instruct them to post. If employees post positive reviews as independent customers, the business faces legal exposure. Disclosure is the fix: any review from an employee, partner, or affiliated person must state that connection clearly.
Incentivized Reviews Without Disclosure
Offering compensation in exchange for reviews — discounts, free products, or cash — is not automatically illegal, but it becomes deceptive conduct when the incentive is not disclosed. A customer who receives a free service and posts a review without mentioning that compensation was involved is not writing a genuine consumer opinion. Undisclosed incentivized reviews are a misleading representation under the Competition Act.
Incentivized reviews must be clearly labeled. If your business runs any review generation program involving compensation of any kind, that incentive must be visible in the review or in accompanying disclosure language.

Penalties for Non-Compliance with Fake Review Rules
Civil Provisions
Under the civil track of the Competition Act, the Competition Bureau can seek administrative monetary penalties for deceptive marketing practices. For corporations, civil penalties can reach $10 million or three times the benefit derived for a first violation — whichever is greater. Subsequent violations carry $15 million or three times the benefit derived — whichever is greater. These penalties apply to misleading representations broadly, including fake reviews, undisclosed insider testimonials, and incentivized reviews without disclosure.
Criminal Provisions
Where deceptive conduct is deliberate or egregious, the Competition Act provides criminal provisions. Criminal liability for false or misleading claims can result in fines at the court’s discretion and imprisonment of up to 14 years. Criminal enforcement is reserved for serious cases, but its presence signals how the Act treats fake reviews — not as minor compliance matters, but as conduct that harms consumers and distorts open competition.
Getting Back Into Compliance
If a Brampton business discovers non-compliant reviews — from employees, undisclosed incentivized customers, or a prior agency campaign — the right response is not to leave them and hope they go unnoticed by the Bureau. The Competition Bureau’s Deceptive Marketing Practices Digest states that businesses are expected to take prompt, verifiable corrective action when an issue is identified.
The compliance process has three steps: audit all published reviews to identify undisclosed connections or incentives; remove or request correction of non-compliant reviews through the relevant platform; and document every step — which reviews were identified, when they were corrected, and what policy changes prevent recurrence. Documentation is what a due diligence defense requires.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are Canada’s fake review rules under the Competition Act?
Canada’s Competition Act classifies fake reviews and undisclosed insider or incentivized reviews as misleading representations. The Competition Bureau enforces these rules under both civil and criminal provisions. Businesses that post or encourage materially false or misleading reviews can face administrative monetary penalties or, in serious cases, criminal liability.
What counts as deceptive marketing practices in online reviews?
Deceptive marketing practices in online reviews include posting fake reviews, publishing reviews from employees or insiders without disclosure, and running incentivized review programs where the compensation is not disclosed. Any review that creates a false impression about the genuine consumer experience qualifies as a misleading representation under the Competition Act.
What are the penalties for non-compliance with fake review rules?
Civil penalties under the Competition Act can reach $10 million or three times the benefit derived for a first corporate violation — whichever is greater. Subsequent violations carry $15 million or three times the benefit derived. Criminal provisions carry fines and potential imprisonment of up to 14 years.
Does the Competition Bureau distinguish between fake and positive reviews?
No. Positive reviews that are fake or undisclosed are still misleading representations. The Bureau does not distinguish between negative and positive reviews when assessing deceptive conduct — the issue is whether the review reflects a genuine, independent consumer experience.
Protect Your Reputation in Brampton Local Search
Link Lumin helps Brampton businesses build genuine local search visibility through local SEO — including review strategy built on compliant practices.
Contact Link Lumin to discuss your business — or call (647) 699-2555. You can also reach the team at contact@linklumin.com.
61 Alness St Unit 226, North York, ON M3J 2H2
Tags
- goggle ads
- Marketing automation
- Thunder Bay
- email vs social
- Interaction to Next Paint (INP)
- social media marketing
- Transactional emails
- promotional emails
- responsive web design
- social media
- Content
- Benchmark Website Performance
- Backlinks Off Page
- Backlinks
- website Design
- Email Marketing Services
- web design development
- Keywords
- web design services
- On page seo
- Web
- Link Building
- Webdesign
- seo for ecommerce
- Off page SEO
- Digital Marketing
- web development
- seo consulting
- SEO Services in Mississauga
- seo expert
- seo audit
- On-page SEO
- seo services
- technical SEO
- Websites
- Ecommerce
- Website
- Email Marketing
- Brampton SEO
- Web Design
- mobile local SEO
- Google ADS
- Local SEO
- Seo